' I think this is a misplaced apostrophe: brands that release. Im sorry you had this happen to you but Im glad you are able to bring awareness to it. ? Thank you for sharing this experience. Still, thank you for your investigation!!! and I had to pay custom fees over the price of the products without the discountplus, it was missing an item. Many cosmetics companies rely on consumer ignorance about potential hazards. Other than a few random blog posts and a Yahoo Answers thread from 2009, there aren't any solid answers. The FDAs position is that FDA has not approved the use of glitter or polyethylene terephthalate as a color additive in cosmetics or any other FDA-regulated product. EUs CosIng database permits the use of glitter or polyethylene terephthalate without any limitations or restrictions, per searching their database. We use dedicated people and clever technology to safeguard our platform. So a humidifier on my desk and constant eye drops and my eyes were finally moist enough to do the surgery again. Craft glitter is an entirely different thing and absolutely should never be anywhere near the eye. So I wanted to get a status update on glitter in eye cosmetics. Based on the three CIR reports linked within this post regarding particle sizes for PET glitter, borosilicate glasses, and synthetic fluorphlogopite, these were the sizes noted. Colourpop (56) CoverGirl (39) Crunchi (1) Dermacol (24) Doll Face (6) Dragun Beauty . . My personal takeaway from my recent experience and after sifting through what little information was available is to use caution when working with products near or around the eyes, particularly when working with larger particles, whether more traditional sparkle or glitter, and when working with mascara wands (Ive poked myself in the eye at least a dozen times over the years) and brushes (keep em clean!). If you suspect that youve scratched your eye, even if youve been able to flush out the foreign body or bodies, seeing an eye doctor to determine the best course of action from there is a good idea. You can find a list of FDA-approved Color Additives here, which will also breakdown restrictions on use or any limitations. The company ships within 3 to 5 business days, but this may take longer if they have a new launch or some crazy promotion. Created with Sketch. Products like Stilas Glitter & Glow Liquid Eyeshadows contain plastic glitter in several shades and classic Urban Decay Eyeshadows (seems like most that were described as having micro-glitter) like Chopper, Gunmetal, and Midnight Cowboy (not an exhaustive list) also used PET glitter. Just the fact that I can feel the gritty texture (no matter how fine) of glitter between my fingers is enough to prevent me from using it on my eyes. The buttery matte and shimmering metallic finishes highlight and control the shape of your eyes while emphasizing the bone structure and, at the same time, adding a softening effect to your upper lids. As per a certain company with many releases including more push on plastic glitter- do you think companies care your safety or your coin? The younger ones may not know about primer and glitter glue and adhesives to keep the glitter adhering to the skin and end up with a corneal abrasion. They don't test finished products or ingredients on animals, and neither do their suppliers or any third-parties. Colourpop isnt the only company making glitter eyeshadow. Light Medium, Neutral, slight yellow undertones. Thank you so much for this thorough and fantastically researched overview! Companies can ask for reviews via automatic invitations. comment policy may be My goal was to do more research and present that information to readers and consumers so that they can make the best decision for themselves with more information as more brands add plastic glitter to their products (with or without warnings). Outstanding piece, Christine. With knowledge comes power! This was honestly a very interesting read! I got my item quick and easy since it was my first-time ordering form Colourpop. Wow Christine! They also don't sell their products where animal testing is required by law. As an older woman I admittedly dont find a whole lot of makeup items on their website that I can use, but I appreciate the quality of what I do get. Briefly, with respect to the second concern: cosmetic grade glitter generally means plastic glitter or polyethylene terephthalate (PET). And disappointment. And Ive seen them wind up on my waterline or tear duct from exactly that! COLOURPOP EYESHADOW QUESTION I recently discovered a new online American cosmetic company, Colourpop I was shopping on their website and noticed several products that are sold with their eyeshadows and liners that have the disclaimer not for use around the eyes. It looks like Colourpop is using red lakes that are not FDA approved for use around the eyes. Eye Makeup Remover. Light Plus, Neutral undertones. Dear Christine, thank you so much for this. When it comes to domestic shipping, the company will not charge you any additional fee if you buy products worth $30 and above. I have had friends who werent as affected as I was with dry eyes, so its worth looking into some more of you still are considering the procedure. It had nearly opaque color coverage in one stroke, which adhered evenly to my lips and was comfortable to apply as a liner as well as all over my lips. -24C thats without the windchill. I have always gone for the expensive high end makeups but after Covid Ive been having to save where I can. Im thinking that learning about all this is a good way for me to clean out my collection some more. Moondust doesnt include plastic glitter from what I recall, but you can always check the ingredient list UD is pretty good about posting theirs! Eye Primer & Base. Eye Makeup Remover. Oh, yes, PET glitter is used in a lot of cosmetics. Consumers will have to look at the information available and use their own judgment about what is comfortable for them. Id love to read more about your day to day skincare and eye care, if youre ever so inclined! The website saysFor maximum coverage: Use fingertip and tap shadow onto EYE liduse a flat synthetic brushthroughout the crease of the EYE and finally, ***not intended for the eye area. My understanding is it is (or was) a better method to avoid issues with things like night driving, especially as they are able to work on a larger surface with this method; ergo more tissue is available for treatment. I wish that they can offer free shipping on any order, so I can save money on shipping when I don't reach the minimum requirement for free shipping. Are they really dry? Christine, thank you for doing this. . The items are available in limited quantities, and you cannot replace them with other products or credit. It was still the best decision Ive made. contact us! Yes. When I recently received a number of damaged items in my order, customer services responded within a day and refunded my order since the items could no longer be replaced. I think pressed glitter should be sold at least separately, if brand wants to include that in their range. Aww thats nice! Find out how we combat fake reviews. Mascara. Its incredible how very small particles can cause searing pain on the eye so magnified! Very Light, Olive, neutral undertones. Theyre both routinely used in most mainstream powder eyeshadow from Anastasia to ColourPop to MAC to Make Up For Ever to Natasha Denona to Tom Ford. Unfortunately, the yellow liner is incredibly streaky. a review will be posted as we can't commit to or guarantee product reviews. Of all the things we are exposed to over the course of our lives Im sure a few specks of glitter are the least of my worries, but I do sometimes think about it, especially with the glitters that are specifically designed to break down. Thanks, Christina! The question is below, and the comment section of the blog has feedback, as well as the podcast. Youll primarily be looking for this ingredient: polyethylene terephthalate. , metallic baby blue with blue and silver pinpoints, Our famous Super Shock formula in metallic icy white! I have worn glitter products for years, too, on the lid as well as below the lash line (not the waterline) not always fully aware of the risks but quite aware of potential risks in the last few years. Thats what kind of scared me the most about it. However, larger-sized Synthetic Mica and Borosilicate products are currently permitted. For example, ColourPop includes the warning "not intended for use in the immediate eye area" with their Pressed Glitters, which have been included in various palettes alongside eyeshadows and Pressed Pigments (another product "not intended for use in the immediate eye area"). They have strict guidelines for what color additives can be used in cosmetic eye makeup. In the Cosmetic Products Manufacturer category. Sounds so painful and awful! I just cant risk it, but I have no problem with the other alternatives. Get started with ColourPop today and find your favorite cruelty-free cosmetics products. The purple liquid liner is perfection. Find the top recommendations as voted by our Editor and community members here! I never had dry eyes to start but did have to rely upon drops for at least a couple years after surgery. Hopefully word will spread further with it over time. Where can I purchase Colourpop products and how can I be sure that Colourpop products are real? Customer service takes a long time to reply but they refunded me very quickly although the value refunded was the discounted value of an item from a bundle. Im glad your eye was okay !! Thank you very much for your well researched piece, Christine. I also found it lurking in some eyeshadow crayons. I think if enough people did and the companies understood clearly just how much business they might be losing, things might change. 1 of 3. The U.S. more or less expects cosmetic companies to self regulate. You mentioned some regulations and Im sure you didnt find much. Dry skin. I was very happy with the smooth order experience, fast shipping, and careful packaging of items in glass bottles to prevent breakage. For comparison, Lit Cosmetics sells three sizes of loose glitter where Size #2 is dubbed small at 0.004 x 0.004 or 101.6 m x 101.6 m, Size #3 is medium at 0.008 x 0.008 or 203.2 x 203.2 m, and Size #4 is large at 0.015 x 0.015 or 381 x 381 m (note: Ive made assumptions that Lits measurements are in inches before converting to microns). They care about profits. Now its fairly ubiquitous. Trustpilot gave ColourPop a 3.9-average score out of 38,786, with the majority of consumers saying that they love the fact that their products are affordable, effective, cruelty-free, and easy to use. And makeup *should* be care-free and fun. However, you can cancel your order before shipping by reaching out to the customer support team. While every cosmetics brand would love to get positive reviews, they all have several negative reviews from unsatisfied customers. The answer is pretty shocking. Long time reader now subscribed. Lip Liner. . One can get an allergic reaction such as swollen eyelids," adding that if a lip product has been used on your lips it may carry contamination, which could lead to a multitude of eye issues. There is also a final report on the safety of synthetic fluorphlogopite, which is also known as synthetic mica (CosIng database results for synthetic fluorphlogopite here). Reviewers complaining about ColourPop most frequently mention customer service, credit card, and phone number problems. The lip stains (bought cherry pop and another deep color) have absolutely no pigment and look like nudes on my light olive tone skin. I know it might be annoying, and people want many colors and finishes in one pallette it seems these days, but then the time something DOES gosh forbid happen, its scarywhom would want to go blind over an eyeshadow look?! Our ColourPop BFF eyeliner review team found that it is also easier for beginners to control, particularly if they want a sharp and defined cat-eye look because the flexible tip can glide on seamlessly with intense pigmentation without tugging or skipping. More. , Make waves with this multichrome blue-violet-teal , Bring the heat with this multichrome bright copper-gold-green , Get the complete Chrome Liquid Eyeshadow collection! Is It Safe To Use Lip Liner On Your Eyes. Thank you! Lip Primer. The set includes the Mandalorian 9-Pan Pressed Powder Palette that features saturated neutrals, which enlivens and defines your eyes in just a single sweep, and rich, earth-toned shades, which flatters and makes you look more pulled-together. Contacted customer service and they would not send it to me even though it was in stock and available and after repeating myself countless times asking why I was unable to get the pallet I gave up. The products took forever to arrive (more than a mounth!) Per Allure, if there's another way of doing something, TikTok will find it, like with the latest TikTok beauty trend using lip liner as a tool for creating the perfect eye look. "Colors intended for use around the eye have to be specially approved by the FDA.". Eyes. The beauty standards are so confusing, just like pigments that are sold as eyeshadow in pallettes and then tiny print not eye safe like seriously, if they are going to do that, they should stick to making whole pallettes like that and let people pick up shadows, vs pigments. FDA considers glitter and mica-based composite pigments to be non-permitted color additives when used in FDA-regulated products, including cosmetics. I've been wanting to try Colorpop for a long time. This pallet duo also comes with The Child Pressed Powder Eyeshadow Palette, a monochromatic palette that contains a variety of finishes from metallic to metallic to ColourPop Cosmetics iconic Super Shock formula. Shop on: Ulta Official Site 2,376 likes, 23 comments - Alice Lockhart (@alicexlockhart) on Instagram: " I just posted this smokey cat eye tutorial on YouTube My Top is from @kad." Its not an issue related to cost of the product, as a FYI! Besides their website, products are available at ULTA Beauty, Disney Store, Revolve, and ColourPop Alipay Mini App. Very systematic, referring to precedents, etc. for more basic information like pricing, availability, and so on to make sure your question wasn't , The cutest matte shade that we lilac a lot , Keep it cool with this icy metallic violet , Keep calm with this metallic pinky lavender , A duochrome lavender icy-blue for chill looks , Keep it sparkly with this metallic violet , A bright gold to pinky copper to metallic olivemulti chrome finish, A warm metallic bronze to gold to greenmulti chrome finish, Be an airbender with this multichrome red-copper-olive green , An earthbending multichrome gold-green-terracotta , Bend all the elements with this chromatic 4-piece set! I might be allergic to ColourPop products! I have some that I think are really cute from Shroud (formerly Strobe) Cosmetics, but because of concern for my eyes and the difficulty of removal, Ive been using them on my lips. Yes, as others have mentioned, you can use eyeliner as lip liner. Light, Pink, moderately pink undertones. It would be great if the world was kind and thoughtful, but it isnt. I have paid much more for shadow palettes and am glad I happened to find this brand. Browsing TKB Trading, which is an old school site where one can buy raw ingredients, their Mermaid Collection, which includes iridescent pigments using calcium sodium borosilicates includes particle sizes 60 to 400 m. FDA-regulated product. Like Allure on Facebook and get more beauty news and daily tips in your feed. The one that does come up is by the Cosmetic Ingredient Review (CIR), which publishes findings and safety assessments of ingredients used in cosmetics, and they published their final report in 2013 on PET glitters used in cosmetics. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Cond Nast. I too am grateful for Christines extensive research and totally agree with your concerns, She. Nails. You can get a corneal abrasion or scratch on your eye through regularly-scheduled, mundane activities from inserting contact lenses (fingernails are often the culprits) to dust or sand getting into your eye to rubbing your eye. One interesting nugget I read while scouring FDAs website for information was that products are to be safe when consumers use them according to their labeling, or as they are customarily used. That customarily used with theor modifier made me wonder if products that come with a not intended for eye kind of warning but are otherwise placed in what looks and feels like an eyeshadow palette would that fall under as customarily used? Food for thought! Baby Lotion. Ginger King, a cosmetic chemist is completely against using lip products around your eyes, per Allure. Service 61. Apply tape (if its very sticky, remove a bit of the stickiness on the back of your hand) with light pressure on the glittery area and remove, and start again with fresh tape, and go on for as long as youve removed as much as you can. I plan on buying many more things from Colourpop. Normal skin. I am no chemist, but find my science degree comes in handy with these glitter discussions;). no glitter is eye safe. From a quick googling, one site listed the ingredient under their polyester glitter category as PET glitter (same as what I wrote about), but I saw a lot of association with it as an alternative craft glitter so Id definitely try to dig in more to see what that means. Lip Plumper. The lip stains (bought cherry pop and another deep color) have absolutely no pigment and look like nudes on my light olive tone skin. Look no further than Temptalia's Swatch Gallery. In the US, color additives require affirmative approval, whereas other types of ingredients can be used so long as they are safe, so the industry seems to be primarily self-regulating with respect to other ingredients used. I tried eye drops just to see if maybe my eyes were dry or something and they just felt odd. They are my favorite posts on temptalia. Shop Now, Free International Shipping on orders over. Also, Urban Decay Moondust shadows are in the same category of risk when worn on the eye as say MAC glitter? I went ahead anyway because my prescription was extremely high to the point where I was having difficulty driving at night. For US consumers, you can report cosmetic-related complaints to the FDA. Thank you once again Christine. More liquid lipsticks you'll love: This Pinterest-Favorite Lipstick . We imagine, develop, test and manufacture all under one roof for next level colour + formulas. I found fluorphlogopite in some highlighters; one blush; six shades of ABH Sultry (Pearl, Steampunk, Bloom, Cinder, Teak, Cyborg); and six shades of ColourPop Brown Sugar (Chai, Jamocha, Amber, Ginger, Henna and Choc). I've made multiple purchases with Colourpop and have been happy so far. Details How To Use Ingredients Wow. I am extremely happy not having to wear thick, thick glasses and being able to see at night. Every glitter eye product has a "not for use around eye" label because they legally have to. As adults, we can probably deduce for ourselves that putting chunks of glitter near our eyes has some inherent risks that younger kids wouldnt think about. (FDA Color Additives and Cosmetics Fact Sheet), It seemed like they were illustrating an example of something that may not be approved for the intended use but may not be is not the same as is not approvedthere are other examples on the same page that said are unapproved or are approved.. Lip balm with SPF; Other. ColourPop BFF Eyeliner is available in various colors such as white, canary yellow, true black, deep sapphire, dark brown, and bright bubblegum pink. Discussion and debate are highly encouraged but we expect community members to answered already. However, the FDA has a Color Additives and Cosmetics Fact Sheet, and they go over special effects and novelty use, and they included this example (which sounds similar to the example provided in their response in 2012): Composite pigments: Color additives used in combination to achieve variable effects, such as those found in pearlescent products, are subject to the same regulations as all other color additives. I definitely have to remember to use mine daily! Support Temptalia by shopping the retailers below! CosIng, which is the EU source for ingredient safety, seems to allow for use of PET glitter without restriction in cosmetics, but the in the US, when Ive asked industry insiders and brand owners that I know, the consensus is that no glitter is approved by FDA for usage on the eye and yet it is clearly being used by brands routinely. Colourpop Creme Gel Liner, Exit Liner LOW HAZARD Data Availability: Limited Colourpop Brow Precision Pencil, Black n' Brown LOW HAZARD Data Availability: Limited Colourpop Ultra Matted Lip, Melonade LOW HAZARD Data Availability: Limited Colourpop Brow Precision Pencil, Dope Taupe LOW HAZARD Data Availability: Limited Colourpop It might also be something where if the first ingredient contains it then that might be more bothersome vs. deeper on the list! Light Plus, Neutral, slight yellow undertones. The duo started ColourPop as an eCommerce business with only 31 shades of eyeshadow to see if people would like them, and they loved their products. When it comes to one of the popular TikTok trendof using lip liner as eyeliner, one that got over 4 million views, it looks great but just how safe is it? This is excellent research, Christine! Thank you ? I would've snagged . Light Plus, Neutral undertones. Per my doctors notes and what he told me, it was a plastic particle that was removed. Find your next foundation or concealer match! It helps to hydrate the outer layers of your skin, hence improving your skins appearance to give it a more radiant and youthful look without adding oil. . You can purchase ColourPop Cosmetics on colourpop.com and at Ulta Beautys site ulta.com. . It had nearly opaque color coverage in one stroke, which adhered evenly to my lips and was comfortable to apply as a liner as well as all over my lips. Is polyester glitter safer than PET glitter? Readers often ask me what are my absolute, all-time favorites, and now you can find my current and long-time favorites all in one place! Fully agree with this 100%. This is yet another example of why you are the best beauty blogger in the blogosphere! If. Also, I hope youre healing well. If you are looking for information about this company and its products to determine if it is worth investing your time and money, this in-depth review has all the details you need to make the right decision. We all super appreciate you. So what about metallic eyeshadow is that and foiled the same?? Thank you for all of your time and research and I am sorry this happened to you. This list is useful in particular for anyone who is concerned about Pressed Pigments (not glitter) as you can look up the various pigments used in a particular shade to see if it is approved for eye usage or not. Craft glitter can be cut from glass, metal, and may be coated in dyes that are not suitable for cosmetic use. The blue liquid liner tends to run. After my headache with the FDA in 2012 and your responses from them, Im convinced they really dont care about safety at all. Also, high amounts of ingredients like fats, alcohol and waxes in lip liner, aren't exactly safe to use on eyes, per StyleCheer.
