Eventually he began to take breaks from his seat, leaning against the wall for long periods of time. Smyth abruptly changed the topic again and began discussing swipe access cards that were used on the base. I was interviewed by NIS [National Investigation Service] for top-secret clearance. It was a subtle way of reminding the officer of Williamss own rank and power. Also available from Amazon, With the purpose of writing about true crime in an authoritative, fact-based manner, veteran journalists J. J. Maloney and J. Patrick OConnor launched Crime Magazine in November of 1998. . His hyper-attention to order escalated in later years, and it was impossible for him to walk away from a fingerprint on his stainless steel fridge without wiping it off. Frustrated by their inability to find Jessicas body, they recruited the help of Williams himself. What are we going to do, Russell? Get email updates from your favourite authors. Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience. Jamie Gillespie was arrested and charged with attempting to intercept private communication, obstructing justice, breach of trust, counselling an offence that is not committed, and obstructing a peace officer. James Downs, managing directorof the private investigation firm MKD International Inc., said a good interrogator must balance a number of interests over the course of sometimes lengthy interviews with suspects. Insp. This page is not available in other languages. . If you are a Home delivery print subscriber, unlimited online access is, Famed detective Jim Smyth's interrogation techniques derail murder case, Canada's largest public sector strike leaves thousands in immigration limbo, Adam Zivo: The CBC has a unique obligation to be neutral, which it is failing, 'Why haven't they noticed the poor service?' Probably the most famous example is Smyth's 9-hour interrogation of Colonel Russell Williams. Williams vehemently denied being aware of such an order, and became defensive at the suggestion that it had been given by someone under his command. . Yeah, no, I understand, Williams interrupted. In 2003, Smyth completed the International Criminal Investigative Analysis Fellowship Understudy Program, resulting in certification as a criminal profiler. He looked at the floor dismissively, as though growing increasingly annoyed with repeating answers to questions that he had already answered. Soon after, Williams tells Smyth to get a map. ?. "They begin circling in and in and in it was a fascinating thing to watch," said CBC reporter Dave Seglins. Smyth then began focusing his questions on Marie-France Comeau, and asked Williams how they had met. He felt cornered, and his fight-or-flight responses were in obvious conflict with each other. Enjoy the latest local, national and international news. There are a variety of factors to consider, The Eco 5 launches in Canada today reduces volume of food waste up to 90 per cent, The best in budget-friendly, lightweight and dual-action hair dryers. . To order copies of And its not issues that point away from you; its issues that point at you, okay? Smyth placed some photos onto the desktop. Justice on Fire is OConnors detailed account of the terrible explosion that led to the firefighters deaths and the terrible injustice that followed. "He didn't want any more public shaming than he could avoid, I assume, and therefore he made a decision to bail out now, avoid the trial, avoid the public shaming, avoid the whole excruciating process of humiliation that was set up for him," Leyton told The Canadian Press this week. Toronto Star articles, please go to: www.TorontoStarReprints.com, Conversations are opinions of our readers and are subject to the, 211 Pritchard Road, Unit 4, Hamilton ON L8J 0G5. Essentially [it] has become more and more precise to the point where, when you and I walked in this room earlier today, we couldve sat down, talked for thirty seconds, walked out. Smyths interrogation violated Mr. Armishaws Charter right to retain and instruct counsel. He interjected his high-ranking military status strategically by adding, I guess the closest. The director calls it a documentary on stage. . . What are we going to do?. Williams didnt want the level of comfort that had been established with Smyth to be disturbed by any unfamiliar faces. which Massicotte accused of failing to warn Tweed residents about a predator in their town, and for suggesting that she had made a false, copycat claim when she reported her assault to police. I dont know what to say, its, um. Elliot Leyton, a Memorial University professor who has authored several studies on serial killers, said Williams "is intelligent enough to know that they had him.". Marie-France Comeau, along with . A condensed video of the 10-hour interrogation that pried loose a confession from the former CFB Trenton commander was shown in a Belleville, Ont., court this week. . Of course, the person is under no obligation to answer the questions and still has the right to speak with counsel; however, anything said after such a consultation remains fully admissible in court. Or you can keep pulling it, a little bit at a time, and that's what hurts. rights reserved. Two women in Tweed were attacked in September 2009: Jane Doe (her real name protected by a publication ban) on the 17th, and Laurie Massicotte on the 30th. Realizing this, he quickly corrected his course. click here. Its hard to believe this is happening, the colonel said, exhaling deeply as he sat up and folded his arms. Let me ask you this, Smyth continued. The detectives relaxed posture and gentle hand gestures deceptively concealed the fact that he was about to drop a bomb on the colonels head. Why do you think these things happened? he asked. Snook said this type of approach relies on having an officer build a rapport with the suspect and listen carefully to what is said. Simpson. He captured it all on video. Well, you start by telling the truth, Smyth replied firmly. McClintic, 21, pleaded guilty to first-degree murder in April 2011. But for veteran crime writer and crusading editor J. Patrick OConnor, the factsor a lack of themdidnt add up. Smith pleaded guilty to a charge of falsely concealing his alleged affair with Katrina Leung, from the FBI. Marie-France made a lasting impact in Trenton, and will be sorely missed by her many friends. Many people, such as journalist Michelle Lund, have commented that Smyth's soft-spoken interrogations are now textbook examples. It was behind that rock pile and underneath an evergreen tree that police would find Tori Stafford, she said. To Jane Doe, his first sexual assault victim, he wrote: I apologize for having traumatized you the way I did. Williams had chosen to place her body off to the side of a rarely used, unpaved access road about six miles east of Tweed. The detectives words fought gallantly for the women who no longer had a voice. ", "I just want people to know how hurtful this is, how harmful this has been. Williams hid the body in his garage. He really didnt understand himself any better than the detective did. While appearing to be looking for drunk drivers, officers asked occupants of vehicles questions pertinent to the search for Lloyd, and examined tires. . Sgt. After 10 years of front line policing. Brent Snook, a forensic psychologist and professor at Memorial University, said Smyth's interview was highly professional and non-confrontational in nature. Mark Mendelson, a retired homicide investigator, said Williams has the air of someone who does not think he is about to get caught. After several minutes of backpedaling, the detective managed to salvage the interview and refocus on the aspects that had been breaking the colonels resolve. Marie-France Comeau, along with 86 other charges. September 21, 1995. These are identical, okay? He then stumbled over the pronunciation of their names and forgot the order in which the crimes occurred. Williams cast his eyes downward. Smyth is biting, even to the point of doubting the honesty of his testimony under oath. Cal Miller and Ian Robertson, How a Colonel Became a Killer (2011). Russell, the officer prodded. Williams was stripped of rank and dismissed from the Canadian Forces. To order Constables went door-to-door in search of information that might lead them to the prowler locals called the Tweed Creeper. Sometimes Williams walked in through unlocked doors. Box 500 Station A Toronto, ON Canada, M5W 1E6. . Over the next 10 hours, Williams gave a detailed confession around Lloyd, but also Corporal Marie-Frances Comeau and at least two other cases initially.The Behavior Panel is a group made up of the world's top body language and behavior experts, Mark Bowden, Scott Rouse, Greg Hartley, and Chase Hughes. Im just going to move your gloves, Smyth said, motioning to a tabletop recorder that they were blocking. "Its a science and an art," he said. In 2012, Smyth was promoted as detective inspector to the OPP's major criminal investigations branch as a major case manager. Williams was married to Mary Elizabeth Harriman. You and I both know that the unknown offender male DNA on Marie-Frances body is going to be matched to you, quite possibly before the evenings over. Marie-France was a professional, caring and compassionate woman who earned the respect of all with whom she came into contact. .. Smyth played a key role in the Stafford case even before the interrogation of Williams. Smyth talked briefly about the four crimes that had by now obviously been linked: the two sexual assaults in Tweed, the sex murder of Marie-France Comeau, and the suspicious disappearance of Jessica Lloyd. Listen to me for a second, okay? the detective demanded. Williams finally gave up all pretence of innocence. Over the hours that passed, Williams succumbed to both mental and physical distress. Lifetime hobby: OPP Detective Sgt. Smyth asked him if he was concerned about whether the Buccal (DNA) swab they had taken would match any samples taken from the four crime scenes. Really? The pitch of Williamss voice rose as the word stretched from his lips. In those cases, conventional wisdom dictates that the interrogator should say little or nothing while the suspect stews. Thanks for contributing to The Canadian Encyclopedia. Sgt. 13 years to the day that he was acquitted of the murders in Brentwood, Simpson was convicted of robbery and kidnapping and was later sentenced up to 33 years. Had he been there at any time? Major successes include his work on the interrogation of Michael Briere, who confessed to killing 10-year-old Holly Jones in Toronto in 2003, and his profiling in the case of Tori Stafford, 9, which led him to discover the girls remains by following a hunch to a rural field. [1][2][3][4] Smyth also discovered the remains of Tori Stafford.[5]. Jim Smith Director of Law Enforcement Relations Chief of Police (Ret. .. What do four of the world's top body language, behavior, and interrogation experts want to know from Ontario Provincial Police Detective Superintendent Jim Smyth? The detective took a strategic pause to build his quarrys anticipation before revealing another photograph. From that moment, Williams was under police surveillance. In 2012, Smyth was recently promoted to the OPP's major Criminal Investigations Branch as a major case manager.Russell Williams is a Canadian convicted of homicide and former colonel in the Canadian Forces.In late January 2010, the Ontario Provincial Police discovered evidence that led them to suspect Williams' involvement in Jessica Lloyd's disappearance and suspected links to two other crimes that had been committed in close proximity to other locations near Williams previous home. Ontario Provincial Police is part of the Government industry, and located in Canada. . But I do want to talk to you, Jim, the colonel said wistfully as the officer turned to leave the room. But now Detective-Sergeant Smyths sly charm and relentless pursuit of confessions have derailed a major prosecution, leading a judge to rule a suspected murderers admission of guilt was involuntary and possibly false, and therefore inadmissible. The isolated stretch of road would soon be flooded with police. Colonel Williams sniffled. Sgt. All In the months that followed, Williams broke into other residences in Tweed and the Belleville area. At some point during the evening, Colonel Russell Williams was formally arrested for the murders of Marie-France Comeau and Jessica Lloyd, as well as the two sexual assaults against Laurie Massicotte and Jane Doe. First, Williams was told that he was not under any obligation to talk to the officer. It began as a casual chat, in which Det.-Sgt. Perry said the killer's body language reveals that his defeat is beginning to sink in. He recorded it all on video and with photographs. . Williams raped her and made her pose for photographs. Comeau was also a member of the Canadian Forces who worked on the same base as Williams. Detective Inspector (formerly Detective Sergeant), "Top OPP interrogator credited with McClintic, Williams confessions | CBC News", "Famed detective Jim Smyth's interrogation techniques derail murder case", "Veteran detectives share stories of PTSD", "OPP officer tells of how he discovered Tori Stafford's body", "Christie Blatchford: A sketch and a hunch led Jim Smyth to find Tori Stafford's body", "James Smyth's Order of Merit of the Police Forces Citation", "Detectives in Russell Williams case honoured by Governor General", "James Smyth's Queen Elizabeth II Diamond Jubilee Medal Citation", "James Smyth's Police Exemplary Service Medal Citation", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Jim_Smyth&oldid=1147621219, This page was last edited on 1 April 2023, at 03:35. I only met her once; she was on a crew I was on just after I got to the base, he said. . Okay. Smyth asked him about what kind of feelings he experienced with Jessica, having spent almost twenty-four hours together. ", Eventually, Williams reveals that he is concerned about the fact the OPP will soon be "tearing apart my wife's brand new house. Perry said that's when Smyth takes control and repeatedly suggests that the evidence points to Williams as the killer. "Let's tear that Band-Aid off. Ontario Provincial Police Det. Other associates, such as Paul Ferguson, the program director at Belleville country music radio station Cool 100, recalled that at the annual wing commander's golf tournament in 2009, Col. Williams, an avid golfer, couldn't use a driver because he said it would ruin his back. An interrogation is when we decide to confront somebody on the fact that we believe that they may be responsible for something and challenge them on the information we have and maybe at that point decide to put evidence to them to show them what we know about the investigation and to encourage them to essentially tell us the truth if theyve been holding back.". Your opportunity to take some control here. Ottawa Sun ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition to view on any device, share and comment on. Photo by Northern News / KL . But now his sly charm and relentless pursuit of confessions have derailed a major prosecution. Russ, is there anything you want from me, is there anything you want me to explain. And he was right. During this exchange, the colonels words became more assertive, his mind clearly focused, and his body language much more confident. He was introduced to Detective-Sergeant Jim Smyth, a forty-something, slightly bookish, unassuming officer in a dark suit and tie. Okay, Ill read this off to you, see if it rings a bell. I thought she was a very nice girl, Williams said. . "I moved one rock aside. Plus, special edition NP Platformed and First Reading newsletters and virtual events. At the University of Toronto's Scarborough campus residence, he was known for demanding cleanliness, and he was repeatedly bugged about his obsessive compulsive-type behaviour. A third lawsuit, filed by Laurie Massicotte, targeted not only Williams and Harriman, but also the Ontario Provincial Police which Massicotte accused of failing to warn Tweed residents about a predator in their town, and for suggesting that she had made a false, copycat claim when she reported her assault to police. Other times he gained entry by cutting a screen, forcing a window open, or picking a lock. So that brings him down," said Mendelson. Unlimited online access to National Post and 15 news sites with one account. When he returned later that same evening, he drove straight back to Ottawa to help his wife with some unpacking, since he had the Monday off work. Williams raped her and made her pose for photographs. "He just thought he was going to outsmart everybody else and talk his way right out of it," Mendelson told CTV Toronto after viewing the video of the confession. As a pilot of VIP transport planes, he had passengers such as Prime Minister Jean Chrtien, and Queen Elizabeth II and Prince Philip. presentation-ready copies of Toronto Star content for distribution . Cpl. Brenda McGillvray. [4] When it comes to police interrogations, the law in Canada varies significantly from its American cousin. . . It's at this point where Williams "is absorbing everything that's just been said to him and that's for the first time that he knows that he's caught," Perry said. Jim Munsterman, Alicia Lampert and Bill Holmes. . Chicago police officers implicated in the wake of a political scandal within the Chicago Police Department, or CPD, have retired, dodging disciplinary action while holding on to pensions worth more. . consistent with a Pathfinder. Exclusive articles by Conrad Black, Barbara Kay, Rex Murphy and others. Smyth showed no sweat, no anxiety; but within an hour, Williams was telling lies every which way but loose, while his body language confessed that he was lying; and halfway through the afternoon, Williams cracked and confessed to all his crimes.In 2007 Smyth began working with the Ontario Provincial Police force's Polygraph Unit, Behavioral Sciences and Analysis Services. Sources close to the investigation scoff at the idea that the cat was a possible trigger - and not merely because it sounds so absurd, but more so because it can't be squared with the chronology of Col. William's dark descent; Curio's death took place more than a year after Col. Williams began his string of lingerie thefts. The detective broke the cold silence. It wouldn't be until July 17, 2009, that police got the break they needed to find Tori's remains. . 1:19. However,Smyth and the OPP told CBC Toronto they are opposed to the production and Smyth fully supports the efforts of Lloyd's family and friends to stop it. Williams hid the body in his garage. Lloyds ordeal continued until about 8:15 p.m., when Williams cracked her skull with a flashlight and strangled her with a piece of rope. A notable example is Smyth's nine-hour interrogation of Colonel Russell Williams. So on that July day more than 14 weeks after Tori disappeared outside her elementary school in Woodstock, when Smyth drove down the Concession 6 sideroad southeast of Mount Forest, a house that he saw stopped him in his tracks, he testified Friday at Rafferty's trial. Smyth was not the only police officer to be criticized in the ruling. The looming DNA test that will inevitably identify him as being a killer. A much more formal letter of condolence had been sent to Mr. Comeau on official Office of the Wing Commander military stationery on December 1, 2009, written and signed in the capacity of Marie-Frances commanding officer. But I also know your minds racing right now, okay? When police raided his two homes, they not only uncovered a neatly catalogued trove of women's underwear and videotapes of the slayings, but hundreds of digital photos of the cat in a variety of. Smyth used the controversial 'Reid technique' with Williams, getting the former CFB Trenton commander to confess to brutally raping and killing Jessica Lloyd and Cpl. . When he returned twenty-five minutes later, Williams had written nothing. Please let me know whether there is anything I can do to help you during this very difficult time. Russell Williams is interrogated by OPP Det-Sgt. Williams was married to Mary Elizabeth Harriman. Access articles from across Canada with one account. Canada ends evacuation flights from Sudan over 'deteriorating security situation', Royal Family unveils sneak peek of King Charles III and Queen Camillas coronation robes, Widening manhunt for Texas gunman slowed by 'zero leads', Tom Mulcair: Should Trudeau lead the Liberals against Poilievre? A Sergeant at Ontario Provincial Police Ed Johnson is a Sergeant at Ontario Provincial Police based in Orillia, Ontario. So am I, said Smyth. Jim Smyth taking on Russell Williams in 2010. Smyth is seen in the interrogation videos at first trying to earn Williams's trust and offering access to a lawyer. To Laurie Massicotte, his second sexual assault victim, he wrote: I am sorry for having hurt you the way I did. . Used across North America, police don't rely solely on the Reid technique. cause Ive met guys who actually kind of enjoyed the notoriety. Marie-France Comeau. Smyth chuckled and changed the subject again, asking the colonel whether he ever watched the television show CSIas he segued into a discussion about DNA evidence and modern advances in forensic testing procedures. transporting, you know, our troops for the first leg out of Edmonton [to Afghanistan]; we tend to hopscotch them across, Williams explained, using a chopping motion with his hand. LONDON, ONT. Williams often spent time at a cottage he owned on Cosy Cove Lane in the village of Tweed, Ontario, 53 kilometers from Trenton. Williamss next victim was Jessica Lloyd. whether its you or whether its anybody else, all right?. The detective explained how his computers would be forensically analyzed and that no stone would be left unturned. The Ontario Crown announced Monday it will not appeal the Sept. 26 decision of Mr. Justice Kenneth A. Langdon that Det.-Sgt. Mild-mannered in his approach and soft-spoken by nature, Smyth was not the type of fellow one would suspect of being a police officer. . Unlimited online access to Ottawa Sun and 15 news sites with one account. . . He sat up and crossed his arms as he quietly contemplated his next step. But thepsychologist isso bothered by the 90-production, scheduled to run March 3-12, she has decided to hand out pamphlets to theatre-goers on opening night tonight to remind them of the victims. Jim Smyth at Ottawa Police . Closed Captioning and Described Video is available for many CBC shows offered on CBC Gem. I can tell you that she did not suspect that the end was comingJessica was happy because she believed she was going home. He spent the next eight months in the Quinte Detention Centre in Napanee, from which he made several court appearances via video link. "That hierarchy's gone now, that special status is gone. Well, I think I killed her because I knew her story would be recognized. He feared that the ritualistic behavior of having his victims pose for explicit photographs would have caused the crimes to be linked together. Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword. Both officers were shot and killed . Attorney General Merrick Garland on Friday tapped Jack Smith, a longtime federal prosecutor and former head of the Justice Department's public integrity section, as special counsel to oversee the . Over the next two hours, Williams repeatedly raped Comeau, beating her viciously if she resisted. Van Allen concluded that the prowler posed an increasing danger for a hands on sexual assault.. I am a Staff Sergeant for General Patrol Training at the OPP, Provincial Police Academy. Williams is considered one of the most heinous criminals in Canadian history. In 2006, he completed the Canadian Police College polygraph examiner's course, resulting in his certification as a forensic polygraph examiner and forensic interviewer. When he asked the colonel what he had done on Friday, January 29, 2010, the day following Jessica Lloyds disappearance, Williams explained that he had stayed home for most of the day. And now, just like his four bound and helpless victims, there was nothing the air force colonel could do to escape his fate. The conversation soon took another dramatic shift. I know she loved you very muchshe told me so, again and again. really fast.. Retired OPP investigator Dave Perry said it is compelling to watch as Smyth calmly presses Williams on his links to the crimes. Williams listened to the officer intently, with furrowed brows and a tightly clenched jaw. Theres no issue about what happened. Thats all been explained to us by the medical evidence and the experts and the CSI people who do their job and they do it very well, okay? Which direction are we heading in here? Smyth prompted. Robin McKay has been working as a Detective Sergeant and Identity Crimes Unit and Financial Crimes Services and at Ontario Provincial Police for 8 years. Comeau put up a fight, and was struck on the head several times with a flashlight. JOIN OUR BODY LANGUAGE MASTERCLASS: http://thebehaviorpanel.com/PLEASE SUBSCRIBE: https://www.youtube.com/thebehaviorpanel?sub_confirmation=1 MERCH STORE: https://thebehaviorpanel.myspreadshop.com/FACEBOOK GROUP: https://www.facebook.com/groups/thebehaviorpanelists : Body Language Tactics - https://body-language-tactics.mykajabi.com/body-language-tactics-landing : FREE TRAINING: http://TruthAndLies.ca : http://BehaviorProfiler.com : Body Language Tactics https://body-language-tactics.mykajabi.com/body-language-tactics-landingTRUE CRIME PLAYLIST: https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLguNzIxZa3ERwKVFvXw7ynFGH36PveAtYDetective-Sergeant Jim Smyth began his career with the York Regional Police (in Ontario, Canada) in 1988 before joining the Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) in 1997. But I cant answer that question.. In one home, he had left a taunting message on a computer. . It was a clear case of arson, and five people from Marlborough were duly convicted of the crime. Williams politely reminded the detective that he had already told him that he had been attending a high-level aircraft acquisition meeting in Ottawa that day and did not return to his duties at the base until Wednesday. Less than five hours after he had driven to police headquarters in the same SUV he had used to abduct Jessica Lloyd and strode into the interview room wearing the same boots that he had used the night of her attack, the truth had finally surfaced. Again Williams shook his head and shrugged. We were trying to gather information from Miss McClintic, again, assess her credibility. Police responded quickly. Because this is getting out of control really fast, Russell. Williams victimized families whose members included girls or young women, entering residences at night when the people were away. Ontario Provincial Police. . But sensing that relinquishing control would be a difficult step for the career military man who had been trained to remain tough and withstand intense interrogation tactics by enemy forces, he offered the colonel a concession. Timothy Appleby, A New Kind of Monster (2011). [3] The Reid Technique model for police interviews was followed by Smyth throughout Williamss interview. Used primarily by hunters, there were no homes or other buildings anywhere along the road.
How Did Charlotte Become A Cyborg In Henry Danger,
Houses For Rent Homewood, Il,
Articles D